Insect-Disease Home
Assessing the
risk of transgene dissemination associated with the introduction of Bt
cowpea in Africa
R.S. Pasquet, J.B.
de la Salle Tignegre
Cowpea seems to
be an ideal candidate for proving the potential benefits of genetic
transformation. As it is attacked by a wide array of insect pests, a
genetically modified cowpea with highly effective insect-resistant genes
would definitely have a great positive effect in Africa. However, the cowpea
wild progenitor is encountered over most of Africa and it can hybridize
freely with domesticated cowpea varieties. Therefore, the main concern with
genetically modified cowpea would be that this efficient insect-resistant
gene would move from domesticated to wild populations. Very likely, fitness
of the wild plants would improve, and the worst scenario would be if the
wild cowpea turned into an aggressive weed devoid of any predators.
Considering that wild cowpea is already a weed with good colonizing
potential, this worst scenario cannot be ruled out at this stage.
Results from the
first phase of the project, ‘Assessing the risk of transgene dissemination
associated with the introduction of genetically modified crops in Africa
using cowpea as a model’, show that hybrids between wild and domesticated
cowpea (as well as their progeny) are fit. Importantly, they can easily take
advantage of their inherent protection against insects to boost their seed
production.
Isozyme analysis
of natural populations as well as source and sink trials show that
outcrossing rates and levels of gene flow fluctuate considerably during the
year. Since cowpea flowers are large, large insects are required, and
pollinator species (mainly leaf-cutter bees, Megachile, and carpenter
bees, Xylocopa, but not the common bee Apis mellifera) are not
numerous. Therefore, fluctuation of the pollinating bee populations and
competition between cowpea and other species for pollinator services can
explain these variations in outcrossing rates and gene flows.
An amplified
fragment length polymorphism study of introgressed wild plants did not show
any segregation distortion in the heritability of domesticated genes, and
pollen competition studies show that although eastern African wild cowpea
pollen is faster, there are no speed differences between western African
wild pollen and domesticated pollen.
However, floral
biology study suggests a way of preventing gene flow. The peak of bee
activity in the morning is related to sunrise time while time of the opening
of the cowpea flower fluctuates little during the year. Therefore, if
domesticated cowpea flowers open late, much later than the peak of bee
activity, or do not open at all, gene flow can be greatly reduced. Bee
activity suggests another way to prevent gene flow. Through nectar aroma,
bees seem to detect the aroma level of the flowers and do not visit empty
flowers. Changing flower aroma could be a second way to prevent gene flow.
If these
gene-flow suppressions appear impossible, one could also imagine that the
seed set excess due to insect-resistant genes would not have an ecological
impact. Preliminary results from the project second phase show that birds
and rodents are avid seed predators. Activities of seed-foraging ants have
not yet been well observed. However, results suggest that birds are true
predators, but rodents are predators and dispersers; the
situation is complex.